A long, dark fish moves through the margin and disappears beneath a root. Calling it an eel is understandable, but body shape alone has not identified it.
American eels have jaws and small pectoral fins. Adult sea lampreys have a jawless sucker mouth, no pectoral fins and seven separate gill openings on each side. Those structural differences are more useful than color or length.
This comparison concerns American eel, Anguilla rostrata, and sea lamprey, Petromyzon marinus. It is mainly a guide to larger eels and adult lampreys, not a key for identifying every transparent eel stage or sediment-dwelling lamprey larva.
The three-feature comparison
- Mouth: American eel has a jawed mouth; adult sea lamprey has a circular oral disc rather than jaws.
- Gill region: eel has a covered gill-opening arrangement near the head; sea lamprey has a visible row of seven separate openings on each side.
- Pectoral fins: eel has a small paired set behind the gill region; sea lamprey lacks them.
Look for agreement between features. A shadow beside the head, a partly hidden mouth or a blurred photograph is not enough to fill every box confidently.
1. A jawed mouth versus an oral disc
The American eel is a true eel, a jawed bony fish. Its mouth opens between upper and lower jaws.
An adult sea lamprey instead has a circular sucker-like oral disc with tooth structures around a rasping tongue. The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service sea lamprey account describes that jawless feeding apparatus.
The distinction is anatomical, not an instruction to make the animal open its mouth. Use an existing clear view, a suitable photograph or experienced identification help. Do not insert a tool or finger, pull at the mouth or prolong handling to create a textbook pose.
The life-stage limitation matters here. An adult mouth description should not be transferred unchanged to a lamprey larva.
2. Seven separate gill openings on each side
On an adult sea lamprey, a row of seven external gill openings lies behind each eye. Count one side at a time in an adequate view; seven means per side, not a total across both sides of the body.
The Ontario sea lamprey identification page describes these openings alongside the adult's oral disc and fins. Its separate larval section is a useful reminder that one appearance does not cover the whole life cycle.
An eel does not have that conspicuous lamprey-like row. However, reflections, attached debris or mottling in a low-resolution image can resemble dots. Preserve uncertainty when the gill region cannot be resolved.
Do not lift or probe a gill area to improve the count. A missing view should remain a missing view.
3. Look for the small pectoral fins
Pectoral fins are paired fins near the head, not the long fin along the back. American eels have them, although their small size can make them easy to miss.
The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service American eel identification sheet describes two small pectoral fins behind the gills and long dorsal and anal fins joined to the tail fin.
Adult sea lampreys lack pectoral and pelvic fins. They still have dorsal fins, so the shortcut “lampreys have no fins” is incorrect.
A clearly visible pectoral fin is useful evidence against a lamprey identification. Not seeing one in a photograph is weaker evidence: the eel's fin may be folded, hidden or outside the frame.
Why color, movement and location are not enough
Both animals can look dark and elongated from a distance. Water color, low light, sediment and camera exposure alter what an observer sees.
A twisting movement or a fish disappearing into cover also does not settle the identity. Record those observations without converting them into a species label.
Location adds important context, especially for lampreys. Sea lamprey are native to the Atlantic region but invasive in the Great Lakes, as explained in the Fish and Wildlife Service account. That ecological history is not a reason to assume every lamprey-shaped animal, in every watershed, is the same species or presents the same problem.
Ontario also lists several native lampreys among similar species. A confident identification as lamprey is therefore not automatically a confirmed identification as sea lamprey.
Make an identification record without extending the encounter
Keep the location, date, approximate observed size and visible features together. Retain the original photograph rather than relying only on a heavily cropped or sharpened copy.
A useful note might read: “Long-bodied fish; pectoral fin visible; mouth partly obscured; no clear view of the gill opening.” That separates evidence from assumption.
Where identification remains uncertain, seek appropriate local fisheries assistance using the observations already available. Do not move an animal to another waterbody or keep handling it solely to complete a photograph.

Keep identification separate from fishing equipment
This comparison is not a recommendation to target lampreys or a universal American-eel rig. Establish the actual fishery and appropriate local method before choosing tackle.
For an equipment-specification example, the GOOFISH BassMaster MH rod lists approximately 195 cm one-piece construction, a 10–30 g lure range and 10–20 lb line guidance. Those are lure-fishing specifications, not blanket approval for an eel bait-and-sinker arrangement.
The GOOFISH BCS250 baitcasting reel lists 6.18:1 gearing and separate retrieve-hand options. Choose a compatible casting-rod configuration and assess actual capacity and handling; the ratio alone does not select the complete outfit.
For GOOFISH Max-8 braided mainline, verify the selected specification and complete connection system. Do not infer strength, diameter or supplied length from the name.
A GOOFISH hook-removal kit should be assessed for actual reach, supplied tools and hook compatibility. It is not a device for opening a mouth for identification or probing gill openings.
These are separate specification references, not a tested eel-fishing kit. Prepare appropriate landing equipment and visible working space before fishing, and never use a rod or reel to lift a fish.
Eel-like bait names are a separate question
A packet marked sandeel does not describe a young American eel or a lamprey. The sandeel-versus-eel guide explains the distinction between sand lances, eel life stages and artificial imitations.
Keep three questions separate: what animal was observed, what bait or lure is being discussed, and which equipment suits the intended presentation. One slender outline cannot answer all three.
American eel vs sea lamprey FAQ
Is a sea lamprey a type of eel?
No. It is a jawless fish, not a true eel.
How many gill openings should an adult sea lamprey show?
Seven on each side, where the view is adequate.
Do lampreys have no fins at all?
No. Adult sea lampreys have dorsal fins but lack paired pectoral and pelvic fins.
Can a hidden pectoral fin prove the fish is a lamprey?
No. Absence from the image is not proof of anatomical absence.
Does this key identify every lamprey species or larva?
No. Use an appropriate regional and life-stage reference for finer identification.
Check the mouth, read the gill region and look for paired fins. When the view is incomplete, preserve the uncertainty rather than extending the handling.